What will Obama say when Boston motive is known?

2013-04-19T00:00:00Z What will Obama say when Boston motive is known?Charles Krauthammer Washington Post Writers Group Arizona Daily Star

Terrorism is speech - speech that gathers its audience by killing innocents as theatrically as possible. Nineteenth-century anarchist Paul Brousse called it "propaganda by deed." Accordingly, the Boston Marathon attack, the first successful terror bombing in the U.S. since 9/11, was designed for maximum effect. At the finish line there would be not only news cameras but also hundreds of personal videos to amplify the message.

But what message? There was no claim of responsibility, no explanatory propaganda. Indeed, was it terrorism at all?

There was much ado about President Obama's nonuse of the word "terrorism" in his first statement to the nation after the bombing. Indeed, the very next morning, he took to the White House briefing room for no other reason than to pronounce the event an "act of terrorism."

He justified the update as a response to "what we now know." But there had been no new information overnight. Nothing changed, except a certain trepidation about the original omission.

There was no need to be so sensitive, however. The president said that terrorism is any bombing aimed at civilians. Not quite. Terrorism is any attack on civilians for a political purpose. Until you know the purpose, you can't know if it is terrorism.

Sometimes an attack can have no purpose. The Tucson shooter who nearly killed Rep. Gabrielle Giffords was simply deranged, a certified paranoid schizophrenic. Or there might be some personal vendetta - a purpose, but not political. In the Boston case, conceivably a grudge against the marathon, its organizers or something associated with the race.

Nonetheless, the president's nonuse of the word was no big deal. Why then was he so sensitive that he came out the next morning to correct the omission?

Answer: Benghazi, in which the administration had been roundly and correctly criticized for refusing to call it terrorism for so long.

Benghazi, however, was totally different. There, the word mattered very much. There were two possible explanations for the killing of the four Americans: a deliberate, planned attack (terrorism), or a spontaneous demonstration gone wild.

To use the word "terrorism," meaning deliberate attack, would have undermined the blame-shifting and raised exactly the questions - about warnings ignored, inadequate security, absence of contingency plans - that have dogged the administration for months.

In Boston, in contrast, there is no question about deliberateness. Nor is anyone blaming the administration for inadequate warning or protection.

But if this turns out to be the work of Islamists, will Obama use the word? His administration obsessively adopts language that extirpates any possible connection between Islam and terrorism. It insists on calling jihadists "violent extremists" without ever telling us what they're extreme about. It even classified the Fort Hood shooting, in which the killer screamed "Allahu Akbar" as he murdered 13 people, as "workplace violence."

Yet Obama couldn't say the word "Islamist." He wouldn't be tripping over himself to avoid any reference to Islam if it was insignificant.

Obama has performed admirably during the Boston crisis, speaking both reassuringly and with determination. But he continues to be linguistically uneasy. His wavering over the word "terrorism" is telling, though in this case unimportant. The real test will come when we learn the motive for the attack.

As of this writing, we don't know. It could be Islamist, white supremacist, anarchist, anything. What words will Obama use? It is a measure of the emptiness of Obama's preferred description - "violent extremists" - that, even as we know nothing, it can already be applied to Boston bomber(s). Which means, the designation is meaningless.

Charles Krauthammer's email address is letters@charleskrauthammer.com

Copyright 2014 Arizona Daily Star. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Video

Featured businesses

View more...

Deals, offers & events

View more...

HDS Inc. NOW HIRING

Hiring event December 10th at our office.  We will be hiring f…

Crystal Clean Estimates

Call today for an estimate!

Event Calendar

Today's events | Add an event

Most viewed: