They are impolite questions, but they must be asked: What did Jorge Mario Bergoglio know, and when did he know it, about Argentina's brutal "Dirty War" against suspected leftists in which thousands were tortured and killed? More important, what did the newly chosen Pope Francis do?
When a military junta seized power in 1976, Bergoglio - elected Wednesday by the College of Cardinals as the first Latin American to become pope - was the head of the Jesuit order in Argentina. His elevation to the papacy occasioned joy and national pride in his homeland - but also, for some, brought back memories of Argentina's darkest days.
In other South American countries that suffered under military rule during the 1970s, the Catholic Church served as a focal point of resistance. In Chile, for example, the church crusaded for human rights and pressed the government of Gen. Augusto Pinochet to account for the many activists who "disappeared" into custody, often never to be seen again.
The dictatorship in Argentina was the most savage of all. At least 10,000 and perhaps as many as 30,000 people suspected of leftist involvement were killed. Victims would be snatched, interrogated under torture for weeks or months, and then executed. Some were dispatched by being drugged, loaded into aircraft and shoved out into the Rio de la Plata or the Atlantic Ocean to drown.
The church in Argentina, however, was comparatively passive in the face of this horror - some would say complicit. Church leaders never confronted the military regime the way their counterparts did in Chile; nor did they encourage or permit grass-roots activism at the parish level, as developed in Brazil. On the contrary, the church allowed Argentina's ruling generals and admirals to cloak themselves in religiosity and claim that somehow, in their sinister rampage, they were serving God's will.
Questions about Bergoglio involve an incident that took place in 1976, shortly after the military seized power: Two Jesuit priests who had been under his supervision were kidnapped, held without charges, interrogated and tortured. They were finally released after five months; several laypeople arrested in the same operation were killed.
Both priests were followers of the left-wing "liberation theology" movement; Bergoglio was not. As their superior, he had told them to cease the work they were doing in a slum neighborhood on the outskirts of Buenos Aires. The allegation is that Bergoglio, knowing the men were in danger of being targeted by the military, withdrew the Jesuit order's protection from them because of their disobedience.
This charge was first made in 1986 by Emilio Mignone, one of Argentina's most respected human-rights activists, in a book about the relationship between the church and the dictatorship. Left-leaning journalist Horacio Verbitsky took it up again in his 2005 book "El Silencio."
Bergoglio has consistently denied the allegation. He told a biographer that the priests left the Jesuit order voluntarily and that he appealed privately to leaders of the junta for the priests' release.
Bergoglio also told the biographer that he often allowed people sought by the military to hide on church property. In testimony before an official tribunal in 2010, he said he was unaware of the military government's worst excesses until after the fact.
Last year, Argentina's bishops - under Bergoglio's leadership - issued a blanket apology for having failed to protect the church's flock during the dictatorship. That the church was tragically remiss is no longer in question, if it ever was.
Now that Bergoglio is Pope Francis, his record and recollections of nearly 40 years ago are important not so much because of what he did or did not do but because of what lessons he did or did not learn. There were Catholic prelates who collaborated with the dictators and those who opposed them. Bergoglio was in the middle. He disapproved, surely. He did what he could. But by his own admission, he didn't try to change the world.
Now he has more than the duty to lead 1.2 billion Catholics. He also has a chance to atone.
Email Eugene Robinson at firstname.lastname@example.org