3. Tyler Williams, QB, 2013
While some may consider him an unorthodox quarterback, Williams couldn't have been a better fit for I-Ridge in 2012 as the Nighthawks went 13-1 and won the Division II state title, their first ever. Williams was named the Star's offensive player of the year after he rushed for 1,354 yards and passed for another 1,143 in his second year as the team's signal caller. He finished his stellar career with 57 total touchdowns and 4,481 combined passing and rushing yards.